Responding to Reviews Increases Ratings: What the Research Shows

Responding to reviews isn't just good customer service—it's a proven strategy that measurably improves your business outcomes. Research from Harvard Business Review and other institutions confirms that businesses which actively respond to customer reviews see both higher ratings and increased review volume over time.

For businesses looking to streamline their review response process, ReviewSense offers AI-powered tools that help you respond to every review consistently and professionally.

Why Responding to Reviews Changes Customer Behaviour

When potential customers see that a business actively engages with reviews, something psychological shifts. They perceive the business as more trustworthy, more attentive, and more likely to resolve any issues that might arise during their experience.

According to BrightLocal's 2024 Consumer Review Survey, 93% of consumers expect businesses to respond to their reviews. This expectation has become so ingrained that failing to respond can actually damage your reputation more than a few negative reviews themselves.

The data reveals a stark contrast in consumer behaviour:

• 89% of consumers would use a business that responds to all reviews
• Only 47% would use a business that doesn't respond at all
• Consumers are 41% more likely to patronise businesses with comprehensive review responses

This 42-percentage-point gap demonstrates that responding to reviews isn't optional—it's essential for competing in today's market.

What the Research Actually Found: Ratings and Volume

The most compelling evidence comes from a Harvard Business Review study that analysed tens of thousands of hotel reviews on TripAdvisor. The findings were significant:

When hotels began responding to reviews, they received:

• 12% more reviews on average
• 0.12 stars higher average ratings on a 1-5 scale

While a 0.12-star increase might seem modest, the cumulative effect was remarkable: approximately one-third of hotels saw their rounded ratings jump by half a star or more within six months of initiating responses.

How Researchers Proved Causation

The study used a clever methodology to establish that responses—not other improvements—caused the rating increases. Since most hotels only responded on TripAdvisor (not on Expedia), researchers compared TripAdvisor ratings against Expedia ratings for the same hotels.

The result? TripAdvisor ratings improved while Expedia ratings remained unchanged, confirming that the act of responding drove the improvement.

Even more compelling: when comparing pairs of travellers who stayed at the same hotel simultaneously but reviewed at different times, ratings from users who saw management responses were approximately 0.1 stars higher than ratings from those who didn't see responses.

The Star Rounding Effect: Why 0.1 Stars Matters in the Real World

Google, Yelp, and most review platforms display rounded star ratings. This means the difference between 4.2 and 4.3 stars might not appear to customers—but the difference between 4.24 and 4.26 stars can push your displayed rating from 4.2 to 4.3.

Consider the business impact:

• A business at 4.2 stars displays as 4 stars on many platforms
• A business at 4.3 stars displays as 4.5 stars on many platforms
• Studies show customers are significantly more likely to click on businesses with higher star ratings

This means that the 0.12-star average improvement from responding to reviews could push your business across a critical threshold, changing how customers perceive you before they even read a single review.

A Practical Response Framework: 3 Templates for 3 Situations

Knowing that responses matter is one thing—knowing what to say is another. Here's a framework for the three most common review types:

For Positive Reviews (5-Star)

Goal: Reinforce the positive experience and encourage return visits.

Hi [Name],

Thank you for the wonderful feedback! We're thrilled that [specific detail
they mentioned] exceeded your expectations.

Our team works hard to [relevant value proposition], and knowing it made
a difference in your experience means everything to us.

We look forward to welcoming you back soon.

Best regards,
[Your name/Business name]

For Neutral Reviews (3-Star)

Goal: Acknowledge feedback, ask for specifics, and show commitment to improvement.

Hi [Name],

Thank you for taking the time to share your thoughts. We appreciate your
honest feedback about [issue mentioned].

We'd love to learn more about how we can improve. If you're open to it,
please reach out to us at [email/phone] so we can make your next visit
even better.

Thank you,
[Your name/Business name]

For Negative Reviews (1-2 Star)

Goal: Apologise sincerely, take ownership, and move the conversation offline.

Hi [Name],

I'm sorry to hear about your experience. This isn't the standard we
hold ourselves to, and I understand your frustration.

I'd like to personally look into this and make it right. Please contact
me directly at [email/phone] so we can resolve this for you.

Sincerely,
[Your name/Business name]

Key principle: Surprisingly, the Harvard research found that responding to positive reviews yielded equivalent benefits to responding to negative ones. The mechanism appears psychological—when consumers observe management engagement, they become less likely to post trivial complaints.

What to Measure Monthly to Track Your Response Impact

To ensure your response strategy is working, track these key metrics:

Response Rate

Target: 100% for negative reviews, 80%+ for positive reviews

Calculate: (Reviews responded to / Total reviews) × 100

Time to First Response

Target: Under 48 hours for negative reviews, under 7 days for positive

Track the average time between review posting and your response.

Recurring Issue Detection

Look for patterns in negative reviews. If multiple customers mention the same problem, that's an operational signal—not just a review management task.

Rating Trend Over Time

Monitor your average rating month-over-month. After implementing a consistent response strategy, you should see gradual improvement within 3-6 months.

How ReviewSense Helps With Review Response Management

Managing review responses across multiple platforms can be time-consuming, especially when you're committed to responding to every review. ReviewSense simplifies this process:

• AI-Powered Response Generation – Generate personalised, on-brand responses in seconds that maintain your business voice
• Multi-Platform Dashboard – Monitor and respond to reviews across Google, Facebook, Trustpilot, and more from one place
• Real-Time Alerts – Get notified immediately when new reviews arrive so you can respond within optimal timeframes
• Response Analytics – Track your response rate, average response time, and rating trends over time

Rather than spending hours crafting individual responses, ReviewSense helps you maintain consistent, professional engagement while freeing time to focus on your business.

Turn Review Responses Into a Competitive Advantage

The research is clear: responding to reviews isn't just polite—it's profitable. Businesses that respond see more reviews, higher ratings, and significantly better customer acquisition.

The question isn't whether you should respond to reviews. It's whether you can afford not to.

Start by committing to respond to every review this month. Track your metrics. Within six months, the data will speak for itself.

Start Your Free Trial →

For more strategies on managing your online reputation, explore our guide to review management software to find tools that can help automate and streamline your review response workflow.